9780195171532 - Job in Medieval Jewish Philosophy, published by Oxford
Page 1 of 1
9780195171532 - Job in Medieval Jewish Philosophy, published by Oxford
Publisher link
Page 31:
Page 144:
In fact, maʿaneh (מענה) does not mean 'matter' (that would be ענין). מענה means 'reply' or 'speech' and is used in reference to the many speeches/replies given in the book of Job.
Page 144:
Page 31:
This is not true. The suggestion that Job was an allegory rather than a true story was made by an unnamed Talmudic sage centuries before Maimonides.Only with Maimonides will doubt be cast on the notion that Job and his friends were historical individuals...
Page 144:
In the second, “explanation of the content of the matter” (be'ur divrey ha-maʿaneh), he paraphrases the contents of the text.
In fact, maʿaneh (מענה) does not mean 'matter' (that would be ענין). מענה means 'reply' or 'speech' and is used in reference to the many speeches/replies given in the book of Job.
Page 144:
Surely this statement is unfair to Dalia Wiener, who wrote a thesis on the commentary in 1989 and Rich Kirschen, who wrote a thesis on this commentary in 1996.It is remarkable how little attention has been paid to Gersonides' commentary on Job in modern scholarship...a recent article of mine seems to be the lone scholarly piece written on this work.
Similar topics
» 9780190673208 - Oxford Handbook of the Minor Prophets, published by Oxford University
» 9780190693060 - The Oxford Handbook of Jeremiah, published by Oxford University
» 9780198779520 - Dead Sea Scrolls: A Very Short Introduction, Published by Oxford University
» 9780567205056 - Persian Influence on Daniel and Jewish Apocalyptic Literature, published by Bloomsbury
» 9781611686418 - Jewish Rhetorics History, Theory, Practice, published by Brandeis University Press
» 9780190693060 - The Oxford Handbook of Jeremiah, published by Oxford University
» 9780198779520 - Dead Sea Scrolls: A Very Short Introduction, Published by Oxford University
» 9780567205056 - Persian Influence on Daniel and Jewish Apocalyptic Literature, published by Bloomsbury
» 9781611686418 - Jewish Rhetorics History, Theory, Practice, published by Brandeis University Press
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You can reply to topics in this forum