9780899067124 - Schottenstein Bavli Niddah volume one, published by Mesorah
Page 1 of 1
9780899067124 - Schottenstein Bavli Niddah volume one, published by Mesorah
Publisher link
13b, note 5:
13b, note 5:
The word מומר was invented by censors who disliked the word משומד, so it does not in fact appear in the uncensored edition of Rosh which reads משומד. This is also the reading of the earliest editions of the Talmud and of every extant Talmudic manuscript so without a doubt the correct reading is משומד and not מומר or עבריין. It is unfortunate Schottenstein did not have the courage to restore the correct text.Chasam Sofer speculates that perhaps the printers erred, and R' Ami actually stated: One who arouses himself is called a מוּמָר...The above is, in fact, Rosh's version of the text.
Similar topics
» 9781578190140 - Schottenstein Bavli Nedarim volume one, published by Mesorah
» 9780899067476 Schottenstein Bavli Zevachim volume 1, published by Mesorah
» 9780899067179 Schottenstein Bavli Berachos volume 1, published by Mesorah
» 9780899067186 Schottenstein Bavli Berachos volume 2, published by Mesorah
» 9781578190089 - Schottenstein Bavli Kesubos volume two, published by Mesorah
» 9780899067476 Schottenstein Bavli Zevachim volume 1, published by Mesorah
» 9780899067179 Schottenstein Bavli Berachos volume 1, published by Mesorah
» 9780899067186 Schottenstein Bavli Berachos volume 2, published by Mesorah
» 9781578190089 - Schottenstein Bavli Kesubos volume two, published by Mesorah
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You can reply to topics in this forum